The Most Asked Cigar Questions on Reddit and Quora: A Full Guide for 2025
Table of Contents
- What People Really Want to Know About Cigars
- 1. The Most Asked Questions by Beginner Cigar Smokers
- 2. How to Buy Cigars Online: Common Reddit and Quora Questions
- 3. Questions About Cigar Types, Strength, and Wrappers
- 4. Cigar Storage Questions People Ask the Most
- 5. How to Tell if a Cigar is High Quality
- 6. The Most Common Mistakes New Smokers Make
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Where to Buy Trusted Cigars Online
What People Really Want to Know About Cigars
Every week thousands of cigar questions appear on Quora, Reddit’s r/cigars, r/cubancigars, and cigar forums. The themes are always the same:
- What cigars should beginners smoke
- How to store cigars
- How to keep cigars fresh
- Where to buy real cigars online
- What makes a cigar “good” or “premium”
- How to cut, light, and smoke properly
- Are online cigar deals legit
This article answers those questions clearly in one place, using real user intent from online discussions.
1. The Most Asked Questions by Beginner Cigar Smokers
On Reddit, one of the most repeated questions is:
“I’m new to cigars. What should I smoke first?”
Beginners often struggle because the world of cigars feels overwhelming. The best beginner cigars usually include:
- Mild to medium strength
- Connecticut wrapper
- Smooth and creamy notes
- Consistent draw and burn
Typical beginner favorites recommended by Reddit users include light robustos or mild toros.
Another common beginner question is:
“How do I properly cut and light a cigar?”
Here’s the simple explanation smokers give online:
Use a clean guillotine or V-cut. Cut slightly above the shoulder. Toast the foot gently. Light slowly to avoid bitterness.
And another frequent question:
“How long should a cigar last?”
A standard Robusto lasts 45 to 60 minutes.
A Churchill lasts 70 to 120 minutes.
A Toro is typically 60 to 90 minutes.
Most beginners underestimate how long a cigar session actually takes.
2. How to Buy Cigars Online: Common Reddit and Quora Questions
When searching buy cigars online on Quora or Reddit, the top questions tend to be:
“How do I know if an online cigar shop is legit?”
People want:
- Clear product descriptions
- Real photos
- Humidified shipping
- Verified brand partnerships
- Authentic reviews
Online cigar buyers often share horror stories about:
- Counterfeits
- Dry cigars
- Poor packaging
- No returns or replacements
This makes choosing a trustworthy online cigar shop important.
Another repeated question:
“Are online cigar deals worth it?”
Yes, but only from reputable shops.
The best deals usually come from:
- Sampler packs
- Bundles
- Clearance
- Limited releases
- First-time buyer discounts
Serious smokers on Reddit often say the best value is found online, not in local lounges.
Another popular search question:
“Does shipping ruin cigars?”
Freshness depends on:
- Proper warehouse humidity
- Use of Boveda packs
- Temperature-safe packaging
- Reasonable delivery times
Good shops ship cigars in humidified packaging so they arrive ready to enjoy.
3. Questions About Cigar Types, Strength, and Wrappers
A top trending question online is:
“What is the difference between mild, medium, and full cigars?”
Reddit users explain strength in simple terms:
- Mild cigars are smooth and creamy
- Medium cigars are flavorful but balanced
- Full cigars are strong, bold, and richer
Another question that appears often:
“What is the best wrapper type?”
There is no single best wrapper. Each delivers a different flavor:
- Connecticut: light and creamy
- Habano: spicy and earthy
- Maduro: sweet and rich
- Cameroon: nutty and aromatic
Most newcomers choose a Connecticut.
Experienced smokers lean toward Habano or Maduro.
Another frequently asked question:
“Does the shape of a cigar matter?”
Yes. The shape affects:
- Draw
- Burn time
- Flavor intensity
Straight cigars burn evenly.
Torpedos focus flavor.
Perfectos evolve as they burn.
4. Cigar Storage Questions People Ask the Most
Storage is the number one topic on Reddit cigar forums.
The most common question:
“Do I need a humidor?”
If you plan to keep cigars longer than three to five days, yes.
Another top question:
“What humidity level should cigars be stored at?”
The ideal range is:
- 65 to 70 percent humidity
- 68 to 72 degrees Fahrenheit
Another one seen constantly:
“Can I store cigars in the fridge?”
The answer is always no.
Refrigerators dry cigars out quickly and can ruin flavor.
Another big one:
“What is the best budget humidor setup?”
Many smokers recommend:
- A tight seal humidor
- 65 or 69 percent Boveda packs
- A digital hygrometer
Affordable, simple, and reliable.
5. How to Tell if a Cigar is High Quality
A trending Quora question is:
“How do I know if a cigar is good?”
Here are the signs smokers list online:
- Even color on the wrapper
- No hard or soft spots
- Smooth texture
- Clean burn line
- Consistent draw
- No harsh bitterness
- White or light gray ash
- Pleasant aroma
Another popular question:
“How can I tell if a cigar has gone bad?”
Warning signs:
- Brittle and cracking wrapper
- Damp, moldy smell
- Bitter and sour smoke
- Uneven burn
- Swelling or discoloration
Poor storage or long shipping delays usually cause these issues.
6. The Most Common Mistakes New Smokers Make
Reddit threads constantly repeat the same beginner mistakes:
Mistake 1: Inhaling cigars
Cigars are meant to be drawn, not inhaled.
Mistake 2: Cutting too much off the cigar
This causes unraveling. A small cut works best.
Mistake 3: Smoking too fast
Fast smoking overheats the cigar and creates bitterness.
Mistake 4: Storing cigars wrong
Humidity issues ruin cigars quickly.
Mistake 5: Buying cheap cigars expecting premium taste
Price and quality usually correlate, especially with hand-rolled cigars.
Mistake 6: Not knowing what strength fits them
Beginners often choose cigars that are too strong and become overwhelmed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What cigar should a beginner start with?
Start with a mild or mild to medium Connecticut wrapped Robusto.
Where do cigar smokers find the best deals?
Most smokers agree that sampler packs and bundles online provide the best value.
How do I know if an online cigar shop is trustworthy?
Look for humidified shipping, verified reviews, and clear brand partnerships.
How long will cigars last if I store them correctly?
Indefinitely, as long as humidity remains stable.
Are boutique cigars better than mass produced brands?
Many cigar enthusiasts say yes. Boutique cigars offer small batch quality and unique blends.
Where to Buy Trusted Cigars Online
If you want fresh, authentic cigars shipped directly to your humidor, buying from a trusted online shop makes all the difference.
Explore premium cigars, bundles, samplers, and limited releases at:
SterlingCigarsOnline.com
Your trusted destination for premium cigars online in 2025.
Previous Post
